The permanence of racism—is there any hope?

In the years prior to my dad’s untimely death in 2020, our relationship was tense at times. To be frank, Dad—while he was proud of my professional accomplishments—struggled with the context of my anti-racism work. As a Black man born and raised in the Deep South under Jim Crow, Dad often felt that while individual white people might try to be anti-racist, they as a collective would never give up enough power to create true change. Instead, he felt my work—while meaningful—was a first-class ticket to heartbreak with little to no payoff. 

As you can imagine, it was hard at times to balance the love and admiration I held for my father with his feelings about my work. It was also a strain on our entire family at times, as there were times when I felt that Dad was simply being intolerant and stuck in his ways. Thankfully, we made our peace about my work before his stroke but his words have always sat with me. 

In recent weeks, I have seen the underbelly of whiteness up close, and my dad’s many words have come to the surface again. I have to admit that I am at a crossroads and I find myself wondering: Can white people truly become anti-racist or is this work for naught? 

In many ways, I often find racist white people to be far more honest than so-called anti-racist white people. They don’t pretend to be anything other than what they are; they don’t waste time pretending. As a result, my interactions with racist white people don’t leave me feeling as dehumanized. We meet as humans—I know their position; they know mine. There typically may be no room for agreement, but also there is no room for misunderstanding. 

A few years ago, I was in Tennessee at a Waffle House restaurant. A group of white bikers came in, one of whom was wearing a confederate flag-style tank top. To say that I was unsettled was an understatement, and I became visibly uncomfortable. The man saw my discomfort and pulled out another t-shirt and slipped it over his confederate tank top. When our party finally got up to leave, the man nodded at me and said “Have a nice day.”

Now, that man was almost certainly what I would consider to be a racist. But in that moment, he was a human who saw my discomfort, he knew that he was the cause of that, and he did something to mitigate my discomfort. We met in that space as humans; no more, no less. 

Aside from white folks calling me a nigger, most of my exchanges with racist white people at least left me feeling like “ok I am still a human, even though this asshole is still a racist.” 

My exchanges with white progressive types and others who claim to be anti-racist often leave me feeling less than human. Their strict adherence to following “rules,” their incessant need to explain and correct, and—if I ever challenge these things—well, they quickly wrap themselves in whiteness and double down. 

For several weeks now, I have been engulfed in a situation where a white person has truly harmed me and refuses to see it or acknowledge it, even when other white people have pointed out their racist behavior. This person truly believes themselves to be an anti-racist and while that may be their intention, that is not the impact. 

Far too many white anti-racists cannot sit with conflict, which is a prime hallmark of whiteness—to be conflict avoidant. My colleague, author Debby Irving, has spoken extensively about this. Many white people are raised to avoid conflict and as a result, when they are made to feel uncomfortable and race is involved, they run from it instead of leaning into it. 

This is no doubt why we have seen such a steep decline in anti-racism work coming out of the global racial reckoning of 2020. It got uncomfortable, white people got pushback, and actually supporting Black lives beyond the signs and protests was simply too much to handle—all because their ability to tolerate interpersonal conflict was non-existent. In recent days, I have been checking in with Black friends and other people of color who are involved in anti-racism work and we are all seeing the same thing. White fragility oozing out, funders suddenly changing course, and an increase in tensions. It is disheartening and yet, do we give up? Do we accept that white people are beyond repair and redemption? 

I won’t lie, there are more days than not where I wonder if I am spinning my wheels in this work—where I wonder if even writing this blog makes any sense. Days where I am losing heart. But I refuse to accept that my children and grandson are doomed to live in a world where racism permeates every facet of their lives. Where white fear and ignorance work overtime to strip them of their humanity.

So, in this moment, despite my sorrow, I stay the course, knowing that white folks will continue to be a source of heartbreak and praying that the few good white people will continue to stay strong enough to not succumb to the seductive nature of whiteness. 

If this piece or this blog resonates with you, please consider a one-time “tip” or become a monthly “patron”…this space runs on love and reader support.

Comments will close on this post in 60-90 days; earlier if there are spam attacks or other nonsense.

3 thoughts on “The permanence of racism—is there any hope?”

  1. My response won’t be the usual one, and will, more than likely, be shunted aside for its seeming weirdness. I’m what many would call a mystic, but, in truth, I’m an Out-of-body Traveler and Explorer. 

    Well before I became a teenager, and while yet very young, I reconnected to, and realigned with, my Unlimited Higher Self, my True Self.

    I grew up in Texas, a state associated with what is justly termed the “Racist South.” The state’s racial divide existed everywhere throughout the town in which I grew up. 

    Imagine growing up as a black child in a place where the overwhelming majority of the population saw you as so different that they devised all sorts of means to maintain and accentuate that difference.

    Thanks to my Unlimited Higher Self, I have relived many memorable moments from several past lives, one lifetime dating back to the Beginning of Time when I was more beast than man.

    In the lifetime before my current lifetime, I was a male Jew who died in the Holocaust. I also fought in the U.S. Civil War. At the time of my tragic death, I was a Union Officer. Yes, in both lifetimes I was white, although I have been, at times, alternately white as well as black.

    What if whites living today understood that their resistance to accepting other races (especially the black race) as equals would predestine them to reincarnate as black people in future lifetimes?

    If they universally knew this as an unavoidable fact, rather than just the opinion of another, I believe it would drastically transform how they feel towards, and how they treat, not only blacks but all races. What I have learned is this: Whether racist or not, we all reincarnate as members of various races.

    Consider this: Slaveholders, as well as all whites who participated in the enslavement of sub-Saharan Africans, returned, reincarnated, in subsequent lifetimes as enslaved blacks themselves—destined to receive that which they had inflicted on others because of their skin color.  

    “As ye sow, ye reap,” the all-too-familiar expression, would instantly become a standard mainstay in our world, translated into every language, framed, and hung on every wall–much like the iconic expression, “Home Sweet Home.”

    Next month, I will donate to your cause again.

  2. The hope lies in demographics. The United States is increasingly a majority/ minority nation, with the majority that of people of color, the minority white. Whites are increasingly going to fight and scream, however, sheer demographics will win out – particularly so when we see an emergence of strong leaders, mostly women of color.

    About White Women in New England, one of the issues here is the lack of exposure on equal terms with professional/middle and upper-class women of color. And with this comes a minimal, unlike other areas in the United States, of real relationships with Black Women. The fact that Shay is the director of a “white anti-racist” organization is positive in itself because it does bring this exposure but negatively brings increased scrutiny. In New England, “whites” are taught to play by the rules and hide any conflicts. Hence, any deviance is unacceptable. Affirming the “incessant need to explain and correct, and—if I ever challenge…. .. they quickly wrap themselves in whiteness and double down”. But New England is not going to escape this fact of demographics – just check out the current kindergartens with their predominance of children of color.

  3. Wonderful post…we ALL need to hear your experience, now more than ever. There is much wisdom and insight in what you say, and it’s very important that the message goes out! Thank you.

Comments are closed.